Why Do Onions Make You Cry? And What Actually Helps

You are chopping dinner, minding your own business, and suddenly your eyes are streaming. Nothing sad happened. The onion simply fired a chemical defense at you.

Here is how that works, and which of the popular tear-saving tricks have real evidence behind them.

Sliced white onion on a wooden cutting board with the tip of a chef's knife in the corner

The chemistry in three steps

An intact onion keeps its sulfur compounds and its enzymes in separate compartments. Cutting breaks the cells open, and the two meet.

  1. An enzyme (alliinase, sometimes spelled allicinase) acts on a sulfur compound called PRENCSO and turns it into a sulfenic acid.
  2. A second enzyme, lachrymatory factor synthase, converts that into propanethial S-oxide, the actual tear gas.
  3. That gas is volatile, so it drifts up to your eyes and dissolves in the thin layer of tears, where it irritates the surface. Your eyes answer with more tears.

The second enzyme was only identified in 2002, by a team at the Japanese company House Foods, reported in Nature. Before that, the first enzyme was assumed to be the whole story. In 2017 a group publishing in ACS Chemical Biology worked out the enzyme's three-dimensional structure, which helped explain how it does its job so quickly.

Cross-section of a red onion showing concentric purple-edged layers around a pale center

Why some onions, and some foods, behave differently

Garlic is a close relative, yet it does not make you weep. Its main sulfur compound is a different one, and it turns into allicin instead of the eye irritant.

Among onions, sulfur taken up from the soil seems to affect how pungent they are, and sweeter types tend to carry less of the starting compounds. There is no reliable label for it, though, because two onions from the same bag can differ, as the Aston University author points out.

Because one enzyme is behind the tears, breeders have gone after it. House Foods sells a "tearless" onion in Japan that does not make the enzyme, and a New Zealand team reported silencing the gene in 2008. The Japanese researchers shared the 2013 Ig Nobel Prize in Chemistry for the discovery.

Tricks, ranked by how much evidence they have

Most kitchen advice is folk wisdom. The best recent data comes from a Cornell team that filmed onions being cut and found that the knife pressurizes the outer layers, which then spray a fine mist when the blade breaks through. The droplets are estimated to leave at 5 to 40 meters per second and can travel up to about two-thirds of a meter.

That study measured droplets, not tears, so treat its advice as sensible rather than proven. The numbers also come from a model, not direct measurement.

TrickHow well supported
Sharp knife, slow cutsBest evidence: sharper blades gave fewer, slower droplets in the Cornell work
Fan or vent nearbyMakes sense for a gas, but I found no test of it
Sealed gogglesPlausible, since they block the gas, but no trial found
Chilling the onion firstMixed. Theory says cold slows the enzymes
Leave the root end onWeak. Repeated by an industry group, not tested
Oil on the knifeExperimental, from early lab work
Boiling or blanching firstTheory only, and it changes the onion

The chilling tip deserves a closer look

Chilling is the most repeated advice, and the reasoning is neat: a cold onion should release less gas. The Cornell preprint tested onions refrigerated at 1 C for 12 hours. Droplet speeds were no different from room-temperature onions, and the chilled ones threw off a noticeably larger volume of droplets.

The authors say more controlled experiments are needed, so this does not prove chilling is useless. It just means the tip is not settled. Long fridge storage also tends to make onions soggy and dull their flavor, according to the Aston University author.

A market stall with green cabbages and a crate of red and yellow onions

A sensible routine

Keep your knife sharp, cut with steady rather than hurried strokes, and let a fan or an open window carry the gas away from your face. If you wear goggles, choose ones that seal around the eyes. Beyond that, expect to tear up a little.

Onion tears are an irritation, not an injury, and they fade within a few minutes once you step away. If your eyes keep hurting or your vision stays blurry, that is a reason to see an eye doctor rather than try another kitchen hack.

Photos: HungryHuy (CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons); FJGAR (CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons); USDA photo by Lance Cheung (public domain, Wikimedia Commons).

Comments

Popular Posts

Do Vitamins and Supplements Actually Work?

How Nonograms Work (and a Free Place to Play One)